Main Content

Home » New York Historic Properties

New York Historic Properties

By Vanessa Saunders, MBA, MIMC , Broker Owner, Global Property Systems Real Estate.

The landscape of the Hudson Valley is dotted with historic residences – Franklin Delano Roosevelt’s home at Hyde Park, Washington Irving’s Sunnyside mansion in Irvington, and Martin Van Buren’s home in Kinderhook, NY to name but a few. There are hundreds of lesser-known buildings that are significant to Hudson Valley’s rich history, many of which are still being used as private homes today,
We recently sold the beautiful home above located in Rock Tavern, central Orange County on the original location of the Clinton Homestead. The Clinton property is the birthplace of NY’s first Governor, George Clinton. For its age, the property is in remarkably good condition, especially since it hasn’t been lived in for many years. The property was built by John Springstead Bull in 1856. Extensive period detail remains in the home. The exterior stonework appears to be mostly original with carved inscriptions intact. Inside, high ceilings, wide plank floors, wood-paneled walls, carved woodwork, and plaster moldings lend elegance from a time gone by.

Click the picture below for more recent sales from the GPS Historic Homes Specialist Team.

While it’s a fun idea to own and inhabit a piece of American history, historic residences like these present a unique set of benefits and challenges. If you’re considering buying a historic home, you should do the following.

1. Thoroughly research the home.
Research a registered property through the National Registry of Historic Places. For older homes not registered, start with the New York State Historical Preservation Office , which can provide useful information on the history of older individual properties. This includes any pertinent rules or regulations regarding ownership, renovations that may or may not be allowed, and any available tax incentives.
2. Check to see if it qualifies for historical designation. If your property meets certain standards of age and distinction, it may be worth seeking a place on the Historic Registration. But getting a home officially sanctioned as historic can be a difficult process. The property must first meet specific criteria and be approved by the State Historic Preservation Office. A property that qualifies may be eligible for financial incentives and/or tax breaks, or funding for restoration and preservation.
3. Make a conditional offer. It is a good idea to make your initial offer contingent on two things: That you can get financing, and that the house is able to pass a professional inspection. Older homes are notorious for structural defects you may not be able to see but which can change the value of the house drastically.
4. Hire a professional home inspector. This is probably the most important step in buying an older home. Whether simply by age or neglect, historic homes may require major repairs and improvements to make them livable and bring them up to code. For homes that have stood vacant for long periods of time, this is especially true. Common trouble spots include dangerous sub-standard wiring, asbestos, leaking roofs, damp basements, and toxic lead-based paint, Your inspector will also know how to find evidence of insect or rodent problems. Also high on the inspector’s list are out-of-date heating, plumbing, or electrical systems. When you have a clear picture of what kinds of renovations need to be done, make sure they can be accomplished without damaging the home.
5. Make your final offer. Take any problems the inspector may have found to the seller and adjust your offer accordingly. If the owner agrees to make good on any improvements, either by fixing them before closing or making an allowance off the purchase price, be sure to get these promises included in the purchase agreement and stipulate that any renovations done by the owner will be done without damaging the home’s historical makeup or designation. Be sure to check in the agreement to see if there are any items from the home (antiques, chandeliers, brass knobs or fittings, etc.) that the seller has excluded from the deal. If they are important to you, you may be able to negotiate for them before closing.
6. Be careful when renovating. If you have renovation plans for your “new” historic home, it’s best to hire a contractor who specializes in working on historic properties. Check references thoroughly, because there may be restrictions on what you can and can’t do to a historic home, and not all contractors are aware of them. If the home is in a designated historic area, you may not be allowed to replace doors and windows, or even what color you can paint the house.
7. Keep reselling in mind. The cachet of famous former owners or a connection to certain historic events may not necessarily make your older home valuable beyond its current worth. Some older homes can be difficult to sell. Not all buyers are willing to accept the quirks of an old home or the expenses it may incur. Know the home, its history, and the market, and then carefully be sure you know what you’re getting into before you buy.

Click on the link below to view the list of currently available Historic Homes all built prior to 1900.

New York Hudson Valley Historic Properties

and for homes between the years 1901 – 1950 Click Here.

If you don’t find the ideal property, please call us, we may know of a property

that will be available soon to suit your specific requirements.

New York Hudson Valley 20th Century Property Styles

Colonial Revival

One of the most classic, understated house styles is the Colonial Revival. Stately and distinguished, rather than cute or cottage-like, they are substantial homes that declare that the owners are persons with a solid center and traditional values. Most are symmetrical, where each side is a mirror image of the other. Decorative elements are restrained and drawn from Greek and Roman classical architecture. The entry is generally very obvious with a large door, transom, sidelights, hood, or even a portico.

Arts and Crafts

Today a similar movement would probably be called the “Slow Design Movement.” It would be about the simplicity, honesty, and inherent beauty in a design, rather than about flash, sizzle, shallowness, quantity, and size we see all around us. For that reason, the Arts & Crafts Movement philosophy and style resonates with us today.

Dutch Revival

The Dutch Colonial Revival is considered a subtype of the Colonial Revival style. It often shares a great many of the same characteristics including symmetry, similar siding, windows, entries, and finishes both inside and out. Where the Dutch Revival is most obviously different is in its distinctive profile; it’s not uncommon to hear it described as a “barn house.”

Cape Cod

This is a subtype of the Colonial Revival style and was popular throughout the same period though it peaked from 1920 to 1960. Once the simplest type of small New England home, Cape Cod is seen in almost every neighborhood. The principal advantage of the Cape Cod was its small size and economy. Where a larger Colonial Revival was out of reach for many a young couple or first-time buyer, the Cape Cod was often relatively affordable. Most had living areas and a bathroom downstairs with two small bedrooms on the second floor.

Tudor Revival

During the second half of the 19th century, Tudor-style architecture was revived in Great Britain. Eventually, the style made its way to the US during the last quarter of the 19th century where it was incorporated into homes across America for about 50 years, finally giving way to a streamlined, smaller style that became known as English Cottage.

Queen Anne architecture, notable for its ornamental excesses, is also commonly referred to as Victorian style. Spindlework, fish scale siding, and decorative treatments are often seen on every possible surface. The basic shape is often a two-story with a hipped roof and one or two lower cross-gables, though many are simpler cross- or front-gabled houses.


Striving for “honesty of design” is the hallmark of the Craftsman and Craftsman-style home. Some of the first true Craftsman homes, like the Gamble House by Greene & Greene, were built in California, but many are still found in the Hudson Valley. The open floor plan and earth-hugging horizontal profile were ideally suited for California’s mild year-round climate. The design was heavily influenced by the architecture of the Spanish mission buildings and the Japanese aesthetic that was seen everywhere in the first decades of the 20th century.

If you currently own a historic home and are considering selling,

please contact GPS real estate’s historic homes specialist team at 845-848-2218

Translate »